The news that moves freight
Ocean Nov 20, 2026 · 8 min read

Panama and Darwin: the fights over Chinese-linked ports move into the courts

Port ownership fights now run for years, and Panama and Darwin just proved it

Panama’s comptroller general filed a criminal complaint on 18 November 2026 over the contract that let a CK Hutchison company run the Balboa and Cristóbal container terminals at either end of the Panama Canal. The complaint covers Panama Ports Company (PPC) itself, plus Panama Maritime Authority board members and administrators from 2014 to 2023, Reuters reported. The comptroller did not spell out the irregularities. It sent its documents to the public prosecutor.

Late the same day, on the other side of the Pacific, Landbridge said it was lodging a formal dispute under the China–Australia Free Trade Agreement. Landbridge is the Chinese company that holds the 99-year lease on Darwin Port. It argues that forcing it to sell would break Australia’s international obligations, according to The Daily Cargo News.

Our view is simple. Moves to push Chinese-linked operators out of strategic ports have stopped being deals and become court cases. Court cases run for years. Ports keep handling cargo through all of it. What stalls is investment, and the slow question of who will finally hold the keys.

What happened in Panama

The criminal complaint is the third legal track in the Panama fight, not the first.

The first was constitutional. On 29 January 2026, Panama’s Supreme Court announced its ruling that the laws and acts behind PPC’s concessions were unconstitutional, Al Jazeera reported. (A concession is a long-term contract that lets a private company run a state-owned port.) PPC had held the terminals since the 1990s. The contracts were renewed automatically in 2021 for another 25 years. Al Jazeera also reported that an audit found irregularities. These reportedly cost Panama about $300 million after the extension, and an estimated $1.2 billion over the original contract. PPC said the ruling “lacks legal basis”.

The second track was physical. Once the decision appeared in the court’s official gazette, the state occupied the terminals. Maritime Executive reported this on 23 February. The government said it “will guarantee the operations of the ports until a new tender can be completed.” The terminals “handle nearly 4 million TEU annually, representing more than a third of the containers moved in Panama.” (A TEU is one 20-foot container.) Two new concessions were planned, with a different operator at each port. The process “would take up to 18 months,” the same report said.

The third track is now criminal. Maritime Executive says the audit reviewed the full concession back to 1997 but focused on 2014 to 2024. The complaint targets the people involved in “the extension of the concession in 2021 for an additional 25 years”. The prosecutor’s office says it will review the documents.

CK Hutchison is fighting back. Maritime Executive reports that the company “started a series of arbitration claims against Panama”. It has also “refuted claims from Panama that it had not made the required payments under its concession.” In February, Panamanian media reported that Hutchison was seeking $2 billion. The company did not put a figure on its claim (Maritime Executive). PPC also accuses the authorities of unlawfully seizing property and documents. President José Raúl Mulino rejects that, Reuters reported.

Beijing has joined in too. Maritime Executive reports that Chinese officials called the dispute politically motivated. The same report describes “increased inspections and detentions of Panama-flagged ships calling at Chinese ports” as part of the fallout. Those actions were never confirmed.

What happened in Darwin

Darwin’s story has the same shape, on a smaller scale.

The Northern Territory government leased the port to Landbridge in 2015. Maritime Executive puts the price at A$506 million. ABC rounds it to $500 million. The federal government now wants the lease back in Australian hands. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, speaking in Shenzhen, told reporters: “Darwin Port should stay in Australian hands, it should never have been sold.”

The two sides do not agree on whether they are even talking. Albanese said: “The owners, Landbridge, are engaging and there are discussions taking place.” Landbridge said it “was not a willing seller of the port”. It added that it “was left with no alternative but to take steps to protect its legal rights”. Defence Minister Richard Marles said the government will fight the claim.

This is Landbridge’s second legal front. On 24 April 2026 it filed a claim with ICSID, the World Bank’s International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes, Maritime Executive reported. ICSID is a tribunal where foreign investors can sue governments. That claim also relies on the free trade agreement. The new step adds a formal treaty dispute on top of it. Landbridge has asked Canberra not to strip it of the port while its case is heard, according to ABC.

The port is making money, which gives Landbridge a reason to fight. Maritime Executive reported that in November 2025 it “reported more than A$42 million in profit (EBITDA) for the operations”. That was up 25 per cent on the year before.

Why this will take years

There is no fast route out of either fight. Here is what history and the analysts say.

Colin Hawes, an associate professor of law at the University of Technology Sydney, wrote in May that the Darwin case “may take years to resolve.” He also counted the trend: “Since 2021, 11 cases have been brought by Chinese companies against different governments around the world. Eight of these are pending.” In our view, eight of 11 still pending tells you how long these cases run.

Panama’s own timetable was already long before the criminal complaint. In February the government said retendering could take up to 18 months, which points to around August 2027. It now plans to rebid both terminals separately. It also plans competing terminals at Corozal on the Pacific side and Telfers on the Atlantic side. Maritime Executive says Panama “would pre-qualify, by the end of this year, the companies to bid for the two new terminals”. That deadline is six weeks away.

Then there is the bigger deal sitting on top of Panama. In March 2025, CK Hutchison agreed to sell most of its global ports business to a consortium led by BlackRock and MSC’s Terminal Investment Ltd (TiL). FreightWaves put the value at $22.8 billion. It covered “199 berths at 43 ports in 23 countries”. By March 2026 Bloomberg Law reported the plan was “at an impasse a year after the deal was announced.” Maritime Executive, citing the Financial Times, reported that talks had restarted with Panama removed from the package. China reportedly insisted that state-owned COSCO be a partner. The gCaptain/Reuters report says the Panama dispute has complicated the sale. A criminal case does not make it any simpler.

In our view, each new legal track makes a quick negotiated exit less likely. A government that has filed a criminal complaint cannot easily turn around and settle. An investor holding two international claims has little reason to drop them for a low offer.

What it means for forwarders and shippers

Start with what does not change. Both ports are working. Panama’s government promised to keep operations running until new concessions are awarded. Darwin’s livestock exporters care more about service than ownership. Patrick Moran of the NT Livestock Exporters Association told ABC that exporters want “a well-run, efficient port,” and that “it doesn’t much matter who’s running it.”

Now the parts that do change.

First, investment slows down. Nobody spends heavily on cranes, berths or yard space when ownership is in court. Northern Territory Treasurer Bill Yan said: “We need a decision soon to provide certainty.” Andy Burford of the Maritime Union’s NT branch said workers “would like a bit of certainty which way it’s going to go”. In our view, users of both ports should not plan on new capacity at these terminals in 2027.

Second, in Panama, carriers now control the gateways. Maritime Executive reports that the terminals were assigned to “Maersk’s APM Terminals and to MSC’s Terminal Investments (TiL)” while the rebid runs. For a forwarder routing transshipment cargo through the canal, that matters. Transshipment means moving boxes from one ship to another at a hub. When the terminal is run by a carrier’s sister company, cargo on other lines can fall behind in the queue for berth windows and yard slots when things get tight. We would watch dwell times at Balboa and Cristóbal for carriers outside the Maersk and MSC networks.

Third, the political risk now spreads both ways. The reports of extra inspections of Panama-flagged ships at Chinese ports are unconfirmed. But they show that a port dispute can spill over into how ships are treated elsewhere. Shippers with Panama-flagged tonnage on China routes should ask their carriers whether they have seen any delays.

Fourth, there is the bigger picture. Forwarders route cargo through dozens of terminals in the CK Hutchison network, and the stalled sale decides who runs them. While Panama sits in court, that decision stays open too.

Our call

Our prediction is that no permanent concession will be awarded for Balboa or Cristóbal before 30 June 2027. The interim APM Terminals and TiL arrangement will still be in place on that date. On the same date, the Darwin Port lease will still be held by Landbridge, with both its ICSID claim and its free trade agreement dispute still open. If Panama misses its own end-of-2026 pre-qualification target for the Corozal and Telfers bidders, read it as the first sign that the whole timetable is slipping.

Sources

Read us on Google? Add Forwarder News as a preferred source to see more of our stories in Top Stories.