The news that moves freight
Trucking & Rail Nov 22, 2026 · 7 min read

J.B. Hunt must face a jury over carrier selection

A Denver–Phoenix load worth $1,350 shows what Montgomery means in court

A load worth $1,350 has put one of America’s largest logistics companies in front of a possible jury. On Thursday 19 November, Judge Stephen McNamee of the US District Court for Arizona issued a split decision in Crystal Gee et al. v. J.B. Hunt et al., FreightWaves reported. He dismissed one claim against J.B. Hunt. He let the other, more dangerous one go forward.

The surviving claim is negligent hiring. In broker terms, that means picking a trucking company you should have known was unsafe. The question of whether J.B. Hunt’s choice was reasonable now looks set for a jury.

Our view: this is the first clear picture of how broker liability plays out after the Supreme Court’s Montgomery ruling. The legal shield is gone. What remains is an argument about facts. Judges tend to leave facts to juries, and juries in fatal truck crash cases are hard to predict. Every forwarder that books US trucking should read this case as a preview of its own.

What happened on Route 160

The load ran from Denver to Phoenix for Lincare, a medical equipment supplier, according to the case summary FreightWaves reported. Lincare hired J.B. Hunt’s brokerage arm. A carrier called Borderlanders Inc. booked the load off J.B. Hunt’s online brokerage platform. The price was $1,350.

In October 2023, a Borderlanders truck crossed into oncoming traffic on US Route 160, a two-lane highway, and hit a car head-on. Two adults were killed. Their three children were seriously injured. The plaintiff is the children’s guardian.

Borderlanders is no longer in the case. It settled with the plaintiffs, and the claim against the driver was dismissed. That left J.B. Hunt, the party that chose the carrier, as the main defendant.

The split decision

J.B. Hunt won on the first question. The plaintiffs argued it was “vicariously liable”, meaning legally responsible for the driver’s actions as if it were the employer. They leaned on federal leasing rules, which treat a company that leases a truck and driver as the operator. The judge did not accept that. “Based on the undisputed material facts, J.B. Hunt did not lease equipment to Borderlanders,” he wrote. Borderlanders moved the load “under its own authority using its own equipment.” His conclusion: “Thus, there is no lease, and the federal leasing regulations are inapplicable.”

That is a real win for brokers. It says a normal brokered load, where the carrier runs under its own authority, does not make the broker the employer. Brokers can keep relying on that line.

J.B. Hunt lost on the second question. “There remain factual disputes regarding Plaintiffs’ negligent hiring claim against J.B. Hunt,” the judge wrote. He found the plaintiffs had “presented sufficient evidence in which a rational jury could find that J.B. Hunt knew, or should have known” about the risk.

The key evidence is simple. “Plaintiffs cite evidence that J.B. Hunt never reviewed Borderlanders’ publicly available accident and crash history,” the ruling says, according to FreightWaves. That history sits in public federal safety data run by the FMCSA (the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, the US truck safety regulator).

J.B. Hunt also argued that with no claim left against Borderlanders, there was nothing to hang a hiring claim on. The hiring claim went forward anyway. J.B. Hunt declined to comment, citing the ongoing litigation.

Why Montgomery changed the fight

Until this year, brokers had a strong first defence. A federal law, the FAAAA (Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act), blocks states from regulating broker prices, routes and services. Brokers argued that a negligent-hiring lawsuit was exactly that kind of state regulation, so it should be thrown out early. In Montgomery itself, the Seventh Circuit appeals court had sided with the broker.

On 14 May 2026 the Supreme Court settled it in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II. The vote was 9-0. Justice Amy Coney Barrett wrote the opinion. The Court held that negligent-hiring claims against brokers fall inside the FAAAA’s safety exception, which keeps states’ power over motor vehicle safety. Requiring a broker to use ordinary care in picking a trucking company concerns the trucks, the Court reasoned, as DLA Piper summarised it. The standard of care will be set by each state’s law, so rules may differ from state to state.

J.B. Hunt had used the preemption defence in this case. “But that defense died with the ruling in Montgomery, forcing J.B. Hunt to find different approaches,” FreightWaves wrote.

Those different approaches were the leasing argument, which worked, and arguments about Borderlanders’ record, which did not. According to Gregory Reed, a lawyer at Hanson Bridgett, J.B. Hunt argued that Borderlanders was still an FMCSA-authorised, though unrated, carrier, and that its record had too few negative incidents to give notice of a problem. Reed called these “common refrains in the broker and logistics industry.” He judged them “unavailing.” His read of what comes next: “courts may be unlikely to take these cases out of the hands of the jury.”

That is the core of our view. Before Montgomery, brokers could win these cases on paper, before trial. After Montgomery, the question is whether the broker acted reasonably. That is a fact question. Fact questions go to juries.

There is one note of comfort. Justice Brett Kavanaugh, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, wrote separately. DLA Piper reads his concurrence as suggesting that brokers that “hire carriers that actually have a reasonable policy” and press carriers on safety should not face liability. In other words, a broker with a real, written, followed vetting process has a defence. A broker that books whoever clicks “accept” first does not.

What this means for forwarders

Many forwarders and NVOCCs (carriers that sell ocean space without owning ships) act as brokers on the US leg of a move. They book drayage (the short truck move to and from the port), cross-dock runs and full truckloads inland. Many do it through digital load boards or automated tendering, just like J.B. Hunt’s platform. The facts in Gee could be any of them.

Four practical points follow.

First, check the public crash record, and keep proof that you did. The allegation in Gee is not that the carrier lacked authority. It is that nobody looked at publicly available crash history. A screenshot, a log entry or a vetting score saved at booking is cheap. Not having one could be very expensive.

Second, “authorised” is not the same as “safe”. Borderlanders held FMCSA authority, according to J.B. Hunt’s argument as Reed described it. That did not end the case. Many small carriers are “unrated”, meaning the FMCSA has never given them a safety rating. Forwarders need a rule for when an unrated carrier is acceptable and when it is not.

Third, insurance. Many forwarders carry contingent auto liability cover, which pays out when a carrier’s own policy fails or falls short. In May, FreightWaves wrote that “the insurance industry has not yet priced this exposure.” A live case heading for a jury helps insurers price it. Expect more questions about vetting at renewal, and higher premiums for those who cannot answer them.

Fourth, contracts and rates. DLA Piper expects brokers to seek stronger indemnity (who pays if things go wrong), insurance and limitation-of-liability terms in their shipper agreements. Shippers will push back. Extra vetting also takes time. Cheapest-carrier-wins tendering on short-notice drayage looks harder to defend, and the cost of doing it properly will end up in the rate.

What we expect next

The split ruling cuts both ways. Brokers keep the leasing defence, which matters. But they lose the comfort of winning before trial on carrier selection. In Gee, the plaintiffs’ story is short and easy for a jury to follow: a $1,350 load, an unrated carrier, a public crash record nobody checked, two dead parents and three injured children.

For J.B. Hunt, a trial is a risk on two fronts: the damages, and a public ruling on what “reasonable” vetting means for an automated platform. That pushes hard toward settlement.

Our prediction: J.B. Hunt settles Gee before any jury verdict, by the end of June 2027. We also expect at least one more federal court to deny a broker’s motion to dismiss a negligent-selection claim, citing Montgomery, before the end of Q1 2027. Forwarders that book US trucking should have a written carrier-vetting check, with saved records, in place before their next insurance renewal.

Sources

Read us on Google? Add Forwarder News as a preferred source to see more of our stories in Top Stories.