Canada’s China car card
Carney names his fallback: Chinese car plants in Canada if the US auto deal fails
Canada’s prime minister has put Chinese carmakers on the table. Speaking to reporters in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, Mark Carney said Canada could turn to Chinese automakers if talks with President Donald Trump fail to keep an integrated North American auto industry, the Associated Press reported on 15 November. He made the remarks days before a planned meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen. Canada already lets up to 49,000 Chinese electric vehicles a year in at a 6.1% tariff, down from 100%.
Our view: this makes a quick US–Canada deal less likely, not more. Carney has made autos the test of any agreement and said in public what Canada will do if it fails. Washington has never treated threats like that kindly. Forwarders and customs brokers should plan the rest of 2026 on the tariffs in force today.
Get The Freight Brief by email
What's going on in freight, in your inbox every morning. Free.
What Carney said
AP reported that Carney called the US talks his priority, but said their outcome could decide whether Canada pursues European, Chinese or Japanese automakers. His explanation was short. “That market has become less integrated because of U.S. trade actions,” he told reporters.
Asked whether Chinese investment was leverage in the US talks, he said: “It’s not leverage. But action, reaction.” And: “Canada is going to move forward either way.”
He also set a condition. AP reported that he said any Chinese investment would have to bring substantial manufacturing to Canada, not just assembly of imported parts. “There has to be a manufacturing aspect involved,” he said.
Two days earlier, in Manila, his tone was warmer. “We are making progress,” he said, CTV reported. “There is a possibility of a deal, a bilateral deal, but we’re not yet there.”
US Ambassador to Canada Pete Hoekstra has said he is confident a deal can be reached before the end of the year, CTV reported.
The door to China is already open
None of this is theory. On 16 January 2026, after Carney’s visit to Beijing, Canada agreed to let Chinese EVs back in. “Canada has agreed to allow up to 49,000 Chinese electric vehicles into the Canadian market,” Carney said, according to a transcript from his office. Those cars pay “the most favoured nation tariff rate of 6.1%”. The MFN (most favoured nation) rate is the standard tariff Canada charges most trading partners. AP reported the cap is set to rise over time and that the previous tariff was 100%.
Carney’s office also set out what Canada expected back. “It’s expected that within three years, this agreement will drive considerable Chinese investment in Canada’s auto sector,” he said in Beijing. He said more than half of the cars should be affordable EVs, priced under $35,000 on import, within five years.
China gave ground on farm goods. Customs broker GHY reported that China’s tariff on Canadian canola seed would fall to about 15% by 1 March 2026. Anti-discrimination tariffs on canola meal, lobsters, crabs and peas were lifted until the end of 2026. GHY said the changes “could unlock nearly $3 billion in new export opportunities.”
The deal was not popular everywhere. Ontario Premier Doug Ford warned that Chinese EVs could threaten Canadian jobs and access to the US market, AP reported. That risk is the point of Monday’s remarks. Carney is now saying out loud that Canada will take it if Washington will not deal.
What Canada is already paying at the US border
The US duty at the centre of the talks is a rare one. Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 lets the president add duties on goods from a country that discriminates against US commerce. Polsinelli called this year’s Canadian duties the first-ever Section 338 tariffs. Proclamations dated 20 July set a 50% duty on Canadian goods. It took effect at 12:01am Eastern on 22 August, after a three-day suspension, law firm Covington reported. Polsinelli, another law firm, said that, according to USTR (the US Trade Representative), the three lists “collectively cover nearly $20 billion in Canadian imports.”
Autos sit at the heart of it. The three proclamations target three Canadian policies: its 25% counter-tariff on US vehicles, provincial bans on US alcohol, and dairy supply management, Covington reported. The White House narrowed the motor-vehicle list on 8 September. That proclamation said Canada “reneged on its commitment, ceased negotiating in good faith”. The changes took effect on 15 September.
Three details matter for anyone filing entries:
- USMCA does not help. “USMCA qualification is not an exemption,” Polsinelli wrote. USMCA (called CUSMA in Canada) is the North American trade pact. A qualifying good may pay less ordinary duty but still pays the extra 50%.
- Section 232 goods are carved out. Goods under Section 232, the national-security tariffs on vehicles, parts, steel, aluminium and more, are excluded from the 338 duty. Polsinelli warned: “A product’s general connection to an industry subject to Section 232 is not sufficient.” Each entry has to be checked line by line.
- Canada hit back. Carney announced matching tariffs on $27.6 billion of US goods, covering more than 600 product categories at 15%, 25% or 50%, Covington reported. They were scheduled to start on 8 September.
The wider picture is less bleak than the headlines suggest. Most Canadian goods still cross tariff-free under CUSMA, said Maryscott Greenwood, head of Ottawa Street Strategy, CTV reported. “Canada’s effective tariff rate right now is at about five per cent, and that’s not as good as zero,” she said. She does not expect a full rollback. “I think it’s pretty unlikely we’ll get back to a world of zero tariffs,” she said.
Why a quick deal looks harder now
Our view is that three things point to a slow, partial result.
First, public opinion. A Nanos Research survey for CTV News found 33.3% of Canadians would support a US deal that includes tariffs on Canadian goods, down from 41% in August 2025. Nanos surveyed 1,058 adults from 31 October to 2 November, with a margin of error of plus or minus 3 points, 19 times out of 20. A deal that keeps tariffs is the most likely kind on offer, and most Canadians now say they would reject it.
Second, the auto line. Carney said in Manila on 14 November that his government would not accept a deal inconsistent with a viable Canadian auto sector. Canada recently threatened to sue Stellantis after it moved planned Jeep Compass production from Brampton, Ontario, to Illinois and agreed to sell the idled plant, AP reported. That is the kind of loss Ottawa is trying to stop, and a quick deal would not reverse it.
Third, the China move itself. The US motor-vehicle proclamation already accuses Canada of discrimination. Courting Chinese automakers days before meeting Xi gives US negotiators a new reason to demand China-related clauses in any deal. Clauses like that take time to write.
Trade lawyer Barry Appleton put the cost of delay plainly. “It’s the lack of certainty, it’s the lack of political clarity that’s costing Canadians jobs,” he told CTV. He noted that about seven in ten Canadian exports still go to the US.
What forwarders should do now
Our read for the next six weeks:
- Cross-border trucking and brokerage. Quote December on current rates. Keep the 50% Section 338 duty in landed-cost sums for listed goods. Check every entry against the Section 232 carve-out, line by line. Do not promise clients a January rollback.
- Canadian importers of US goods. Canada’s counter-tariffs stay in place while the US duty does. Expect continued sourcing shifts away from US suppliers on the 600-plus listed categories.
- Transpacific into Canada. Chinese EV imports under the 49,000 quota already move by sea. If the Shenzhen meeting brings auto investment, the bigger flow would be parts and production equipment for Canadian plants. That would mean more breakbulk, project cargo and parts containers into Canada’s West Coast. It would take years, not weeks. Plants need sites, permits and supplier networks first.
- Mexico and US auto lanes. If Canada drifts from an integrated North American auto supply chain, some parts flows now crossing at Windsor–Detroit could shift. Watch for automakers announcing changes to Canadian production plans in the first quarter of 2027.
Our call
We expect the Shenzhen meeting to produce statements of intent on Chinese auto investment, not a named plant or a signed investment figure, before the end of 2026.
We expect no US–Canada tariff deal to take effect before 1 December 2026. We expect the 50% Section 338 rate to still apply to covered Canadian goods on 31 December 2026. If a deal is announced before then, we expect a framework with cuts starting no earlier than the first quarter of 2027. We expect it to include supply-chain clauses aimed at China.
That is our forecast, not a report. What would prove us wrong is a signed US proclamation, dated before New Year, that lowers the 50% rate.
Sources
- AP via ClickOnDetroit — Carney says Canada could turn to Chinese automakers if Trump trade talks fail, 15 Nov 2026
- CTV News via BNN Bloomberg — Most Canadians would reject a trade deal that includes tariffs, Nanos survey suggests, 15 Nov 2026
- CP24 — Carney says Canada-U.S. trade deal closer, but hurdles remain, 14 Nov 2026
- Prime Minister of Canada — Transcript: Prime Minister Carney forges a new partnership with the People’s Republic of China, 16 Jan 2026
- GHY International — Canada Announces New Preliminary Trade Agreement with China (Updated), 20 Jan 2026, updated 4 Feb 2026
- Polsinelli — First-Ever Section 338 Tariffs: U.S. Imposes 50% Duties on Nearly $20 Billion of Canadian Imports, 21 Jul 2026
- Covington — Section 338 Tariffs on Canada Take Effect as Canada Announces Retaliatory Response, Aug 2026
- The White House — Modifying the Scope of Products of Canada Subject to the Additional Duties Imposed to Offset Canadian Discrimination Against the United States with Respect to Motor Vehicles, 8 Sep 2026
Get The Freight Brief by email
What's going on in freight, in your inbox every morning. Free.
Read us on Google? Add Forwarder News as a preferred source to see more of our stories in Top Stories.