Freight thieves move into trusted inboxes and phone lines
The thief on the line now sounds like your regular carrier
Four in ten stolen US truck loads in the third quarter started with a compromised inbox or a spoofed phone call. Highway, a carrier-identity and fraud-prevention platform, put the figure at 40.2% in its Q3 2026 Freight Fraud Index, published on 20 November. In Q2 it was 34.4%.
At the same time, reported stolen loads fell 28.1% from Q2. That is the second quarterly fall in a row.
Get The Freight Brief by email
What's going on in freight, in your inbox every morning. Free.
Our view is that the falling total is the less important number. Theft is getting rarer, but it is also getting more personal. Thieves are not just setting up fake carriers and hoping a broker books them. They are getting inside the email accounts and phone lines of carriers and contacts that shippers, brokers and forwarders already trust. That changes what a good check looks like. Vetting a carrier once, at onboarding, does not protect you if the “carrier” emailing you on Tuesday is someone else using its account.
What the Q3 numbers show
Highway’s own figures point in two directions at once.
Volumes of some fraud fell. Highway says it blocked 670,230 fraudulent inbound emails in Q3, down 14.5% from Q2.
Phone fraud rose sharply. Highway logged 119,022 fraudulent or spoofed calls, up 8.2% on the quarter and up 90.3% on the year. A spoofed call is one where the caller makes your phone display a number you recognise, such as a carrier’s dispatch line.
Direct theft, where the load is simply taken, fell 16% in volume. But because total thefts fell faster, its share rose to 36.4% of stolen loads.
One fraud route shrank. Loads tied to a change of ownership or a sold MC number made up 7.1% of thefts, down from 16.3% in Q2. An MC number is the operating authority a US trucking company needs to haul freight for hire. Buying an old company, or its number, lets a criminal borrow its clean history. Yet change-of-ownership reports to Highway rose 111.4% to 518, and its Identity Alerts rose 5.4%. Highway also says bad actors have moved from manipulating sales to targeting its electronic ownership attestation feature, in some cases offering sellers money to log in after a sale and submit false attestations.
Demi Ramon, Highway’s Vice President of Risk, summed up the pattern: “Freight fraud can hide behind trusted identities and familiar relationships.”
Michael Caney, Highway’s Chief Commercial Officer, said: “A compromised inbox should not be enough to get a thief a rate confirmation.” A rate confirmation is the document that formally books a load to a carrier at an agreed price. Once a thief has one, the load is effectively theirs to collect.
A second dataset tells the same story
Highway sees fraud through its own platform, so its figures are not the whole market. Verisk CargoNet, which collects cargo theft reports across the US and Canada, published its Q3 numbers on 4 November.
CargoNet counted 547 theft incidents in Q3. That is down 33% on Q3 2025 and down 19% on Q2 2026. The two datasets measure different things, so the size of the fall differs, but the direction matches.
The money does not. CargoNet put Q3 losses at $230.1 million, up 12% from $205.1 million a year earlier. Year-to-date losses reached $718.9 million, up 39%. Among thefts with a recorded value, the average rose about 72% year to date, from $261,115 to $448,456. CargoNet counted 19 thefts of $1 million or more in Q3, against 9 a year earlier.
Fictitious pickups, where a criminal poses as the real carrier to collect a load, made up about 25% of CargoNet’s incidents, up from 18% a year ago.
“We’re seeing criminals combine digital deception with traditional theft tactics to identify, intercept and redirect high-value shipments,” said Keith Lewis, vice president of operations at Verisk CargoNet.
Our reading: fewer thefts, bigger hauls, and more of them start with someone pretending to be a party you already deal with. That is not a market getting safer. It is a market where the remaining criminals are more skilled and more selective.
Where the risk sits
Geography is not spread evenly. Highway says California was the pickup state for nearly half of stolen loads, with New Jersey second. CargoNet’s numbers agree on the leader: California had 182 incidents, about a third of its total, and New Jersey had 46. Its top counties include Los Angeles, San Bernardino and Riverside, the warehouse belt behind the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach.
Highway says general merchandise, electronics and bulk commodities were the most targeted categories.
Highway also found that in 87% of direct-theft events, the carrier had a user whose verification history included a non-domiciled or limited-term CDL designation. A CDL is a commercial driver’s licence. Highway is careful here: it calls this a risk signal, not proof that the licence type caused the theft. It also estimates that applying a rule that screens out such licences in the highest-risk states would remove about 7% of available capacity. That is a real cost in peak season, and a reason not to treat a single screen as a fix.
The vetting gap
There is a further weak spot, and it is a government one.
FMCSA, the US Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, launched Motus, its new USDOT registration system, on 19 May. Since then it has “temporarily suspended enforcement of biennial updates and the inactivation of USDOT Numbers”, according to its own notice. A biennial update is the filing every carrier must make every two years to keep its registration details current. FMCSA says that “Registrants whose biennial update was due on or after June 1, 2026 will receive additional time”. The notice gives no end date, saying only: “We will share additional guidance as Motus recovery and stabilization efforts continue.”
Highway’s point is simple. While that pause lasts, a registration record a broker checks may not reflect a carrier’s latest information. Old contact details, old owners and lapsed operations can all sit on a record that looks clean. For thieves who work by borrowing real identities, that is useful cover.
Highway also notes that the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center warned in April that cyber-enabled cargo theft was rising, and that federal prosecutors in Connecticut have charged a man with taking over established carriers and stealing at least 24 loads. He has pleaded not guilty, and the charges are allegations.
What forwarders should do now
Forwarders that buy US drayage (short truck moves between ports, rail ramps and warehouses) or truckload capacity through brokers carry the same exposure as the brokers themselves. If a load is booked to the wrong party, the cargo owner will look first to whoever arranged the move.
Our view of the practical steps:
- Treat every change as suspect. A new email address, a new phone number, a new dispatcher or new bank details on a carrier you know is the moment to stop, not the moment to update the file.
- Call back on a number you already hold, not one in the email or the one that just rang you. Caller ID can be spoofed.
- Do not rely on the FMCSA record alone while the Motus pause lasts. Check it against your own history with the carrier.
- Put the tightest controls on California pickups, especially from the Inland Empire, and on electronics and general merchandise.
- Expect pressure. Highway warns that holiday volume could raise theft risk because tighter carrier availability pushes brokers to cover loads fast. Speed is what these schemes exploit.
None of this is new advice. What is new is where the threat comes from. The safest-looking booking, with a carrier you have used for years, emailing from the usual address, is now the one a thief most wants to imitate.
Our call
We expect the trend in Highway’s data to hold through peak season. Our prediction: compromised communications will account for 40% or more of stolen loads in Highway’s Q4 2026 Freight Fraud Index, which we expect in the first quarter of 2027. We also expect California to remain the top pickup state for stolen loads in that report. If the share falls back below 40%, it will most likely be because inbox takeovers were displaced by direct theft during the holiday crunch, not because the threat went away.
Sources
- The Manila Times (GlobeNewswire) — Highway’s Q3 2026 Freight Fraud Index Highlights Compromised Communications as a Leading Theft Risk, 20 Nov 2026
- Verisk — Fewer Cargo Thefts, Bigger Losses: Average Theft Value Jumps 72 Percent Year to Date, 4 Nov 2026
- FMCSA — Temporary Suspension of the Biennial Update Requirement, last updated 10 Sep 2026
- FreightWaves — FMCSA suspends USDOT deactivations for missed biennial updates during MOTUS rollout, 9 Sep 2026
Get The Freight Brief by email
What's going on in freight, in your inbox every morning. Free.
Read us on Google? Add Forwarder News as a preferred source to see more of our stories in Top Stories.