US truckload spot rates climb early as diesel slides
Tracker Air cargo rates · 3.93 USD/kg
Tracker US diesel price · 6.13 $/gallon
Fuel is getting cheaper and trucks are not: the spot market is pricing a shortage
US diesel fell 17 cents in a week to $6.02 a gallon on 15 November, according to AAA. Truck spot rates went the other way. They are at their highest level since July, and fuel is not the reason. SONAR’s National Truckload Index (NTI) tracks what shippers pay for a dry van load booked on the spot market. It rose more than 4% from late October into early November, FreightWaves analyst Zach Strickland wrote on 14 November. Over the same stretch, diesel fell about 3.5%.
“The NTI rarely climbs this early ahead of the holidays,” Strickland wrote.
Get The Freight Brief by email
What's going on in freight, in your inbox every morning. Free.
Our view is simple. When a truck costs more while its fuel costs less, the extra money is going to the truck and driver. Shippers are bidding for scarce capacity. A falling fuel surcharge will hide some of that on invoices. It will not make the shortage go away.
What moved, and what did not
Start with fuel, because it is the part that is falling.
AAA’s national average diesel price was $6.02 a gallon on 15 November. A week earlier it was $6.19, a month earlier $6.32. A year ago it was $3.77. That is a 17-cent fall in a week and about 30 cents in a month, from AAA’s own figures.
The EIA is the US government’s energy statistics agency. Many fuel surcharge tables are indexed to its weekly Monday diesel price. That price was $6.127 for the week of 9 November, down 16.5 cents on the week. It was $6.352 on 26 October. That is a fall of about 3.5% in two weeks, which matches the fuel drop Strickland described. AAA and the EIA survey prices differently, so their numbers are not directly comparable. Both point the same way.
Now the truck. The NTI is a dollar-per-mile spot index. The FreightWaves piece did not give a dollar figure, only the direction and the size of the move. Strickland noted that fuel effects usually feed into rates with a lag of a few weeks. Diesel has not spiked since early September. So late-October and early-November gains cannot be explained by fuel catching up.
How much does fuel matter to a van rate? DAT estimated that fuel made up 83 cents of the average dry van spot rate per mile in October, Heavy Duty Trucking reported. That was with diesel at about $6.25 a gallon. Our rough arithmetic: if diesel falls from about $6.25 to about $6.02, that is a drop of under 4%. On 83 cents, that takes roughly 3 cents a mile off the fuel portion. That is small next to a market where DAT’s October van spot rate was $3.05 a mile, up 98 cents on a year earlier.
Why trucks are scarce
Tender rejections are the best simple test of capacity. A tender rejection is when a carrier turns down a load it has a contract to haul. Rejections rise when carriers can earn more on the spot market or have no truck free.
TRAFFIX reported a tender rejection rate of 12.9% on 9 November, Heavy Duty Trucking wrote. That was “more than double the 6.2% recorded a year earlier.” Strickland wrote that dry van rejections in SONAR have been trending lower since July but remain elevated. He added: “Rejection rates above 10% is still a sign of insufficient capacity.”
DAT’s numbers show the same thing from a different angle. In October, trucks posted as available on DAT One ran 22% to 26% below year-earlier levels, according to Heavy Duty Trucking. Van volumes were down 2% on the year. Fewer loads, yet much higher rates. That is a supply problem, not a demand boom.
DAT’s Dean Croke put it this way: “carriers are heading into the holiday freight season in a position to be selective and negotiate better rates.”
C.H. Robinson’s November update, published 5 November, said carriers report that fleet expansion remains limited and that equipment replacement cycles are getting longer. It raised its 2026 dry van spot forecast to a 31% year-on-year increase, from 30%. Its 2027 call is for a further 10% rise.
C.H. Robinson’s own shipment data shows the strain from the contract side. It measures route-guide depth: how far down a shipper’s list of contracted carriers a load has to go before one accepts it. A depth of 1.0 means the first carrier always says yes. On long hauls over 600 miles, depth averaged 1.49 in October, against 1.24 in October 2025. On short hauls under 400 miles it was 1.26, against 1.13 a year earlier. Both eased slightly from September. Both are still clearly worse than a year ago.
The last time contract van rates were this high was May 2022, according to DAT’s figures as reported by Heavy Duty Trucking. This time, DAT’s volumes are lower than a year ago, not higher. We think that makes today’s high rates harder to shift, because they rest on fewer trucks, not on a surge of freight that will fade.
Why the holiday rush came late
Strickland’s explanation for the early jump is timing. Citing Dr. Zac Rogers of the Logistics Managers’ Index (LMI), a monthly survey of logistics managers, he suggested retailers waited until late to bring inventory in. The LMI’s inventory levels reading was 66.9 in October, its highest since 2022. A reading above 50 means inventories are growing.
Strickland’s reasons for the delay: demand uncertainty, rising inventory holding costs and leaner supply chains. Retailers that held back now need the stock moved, and they need it before Thanksgiving.
He also pointed to two other forces. Some freight may be moving from rail to truck after disruptions on the BNSF and CSX networks. And domestic container volumes have not recovered the way they did in earlier years. Both push more freight onto over-the-road trucks at the worst time.
Spot freight is only part of the market. Strickland put it at roughly 10% to 25% of truckload volume, depending on the market. So spot can move before contract rates do. But contract rates are already high. DAT’s October van contract rate was $3.28 a mile, matching a May 2022 record, Heavy Duty Trucking reported. Reefer and flatbed contract rates set records at $3.62 and $4.05.
What this means for forwarders
For anyone buying US inland transport, three things follow.
First, do not price US inland legs off the fuel line. Fuel surcharges indexed to the EIA Monday number will fall again if diesel keeps sliding. But the linehaul is rising faster than fuel is falling. We think all-in rates for vans out of ports and DCs (distribution centres) will hold or rise into December, not fall.
Second, the pinch will be worst where import freight lands. C.H. Robinson said California and the Southwest were its largest outlier. Capacity there tightened sharply at the end of the third quarter and stayed tight through October. It cited heavy port imports and vessel bunching, where delayed ships arrive together. It also flagged possible picket activity at the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach as a risk to watch, not an expected impact. Forwarders moving containers from those ports should expect tight drayage and transload capacity to continue. Drayage is the short truck move from port to warehouse. Transload is moving cargo from ocean boxes into domestic trailers.
Third, the holiday itself will make it worse. C.H. Robinson expects conditions to tighten around Thanksgiving. It expects capacity pressure and rates to rise into December, as holiday shipping, fewer drivers working and year-end freight compete for trucks. Recent holidays produced clear spikes in route-guide failures, it said. A route-guide failure is when a shipper runs through its contracted carriers and none will take the load, pushing it to the spot market.
In practice, that means: - Keep inland quote validity short through December. A week is safer than a month. - Book Thanksgiving-week and pre-Christmas trucks now. Spot capacity will cost more once the holiday week starts. - Expect more rejected tenders on contract lanes. Have a backup carrier, or a spot budget, for each key lane. - Use the falling fuel surcharge to explain flat all-in rates to customers. Do not promise cuts. - Price first-quarter 2027 bids with today’s contract levels in mind. Carriers have leverage and know it.
Our call
We think this market stays tight through the turn of the year. Contract rates follow spot rates with a lag, and spot is rising early.
Our prediction: DAT’s November van contract rate, due in early December, prints at or above $3.25 a mile, despite cheaper fuel. If it falls below that, it will be because diesel kept dropping, not because trucks came back.
We also expect the SONAR van contract rate to still be above $2.80 a mile at the end of January 2027. Shippers going into first-quarter bids hoping for relief should plan for none.
Sources
- FreightWaves — Spot rates jump ahead of holidays, 14 Nov 2026
- AAA — Gas Prices national average, 15 Nov 2026
- EIA — Gasoline and Diesel Fuel Update, 10 Nov 2026
- Heavy Duty Trucking — Holiday Freight Meets a Tight Trucking Market, 10 Nov 2026
- C.H. Robinson — Truckload rate pressure builds heading into the holidays, 5 Nov 2026
Get The Freight Brief by email
What's going on in freight, in your inbox every morning. Free.
Read us on Google? Add Forwarder News as a preferred source to see more of our stories in Top Stories.